Why do some people think I'm "off"? Feels like someone mentioned that and others after are parroting without any reasoning. If it's just a gut feel though I'm ok with that. Just be aware that scum also uses "gut feels" as an excuse for a vote, especially during the early game.

I haven't seen anybody directly address me, just being super vague about their suspicions on me.

If you're looking for a lynch you're not going to get one, you're being way too obvious that something is up.

Quieter than normal and a rather 'weak' reason for a vote seem to be the logic behind it. I believe you said earlier that you were at work yesterday and it's why you couldn't be here so that explains being quieter and you already addressed how weak your vote was so I see no issues there but I understand where some others are coming from.

Lol I know exactly how to get lynched and this isn't it. 

Everyone always looks at the grenade, when you should be looking at the pin. Tisk tisk.

Hmm, good point. The problem with the double vote is that if one of the scum is part of the two candidates, he/she will always be able to shift votes last minute to get a majority on the other candidate. That will out him, but that still beats getting lynched. So A planned double lynch will probably only succeed if both of the targets are not scum, and even then the candidates will still probably try to safe themselves with last minute vote shifting. A planned double lynch will be hard to pull off no matter the circumstances.

Maybe not that likely as killing the other could do the same, but that might mess up town morale more.

And in both cases the double lynch would still be in play

Sure about that? A couple of people have already thought about throwing you in the volcano for today.

Thinking about it, maybe throwing you in there today is a good idea. Might as well get rid of the grenade before someone pulls the pin, right?

I still find it super weird that LoC claimed to have a role that makes him not a viable night target for scum without provocation. That would make his power useless if he is town and speaking the truth. So yeah, something is definitely smelly about LoC.

The roles not being RNG is the only way that the story you're claiming makes any sense. You've said your role involved dying and resurrecting. If that was the actual function of your role, and it publicly mod dying on day 1, it makes Rule 34 a blatantly unfair thing to be in the game. It would've let you claim "oh, ha ha Splinter was just joking, I'm just normal!" Since you have a reputation in the community it doesn't seem that odd for a rule specifically about you to be there.

If a good portion of the 29 other players got that role such a rule wouldn't have made any sense. Like if it was "34) Ultron will be mod killed unless he does *thing*" it would've stood out like a sore thumb and I wouldn't have been able to pass it off as a joke. That makes me think that the only way your role would function as you claim it does would be for you to have specifically got assigned the role instead of everyone getting everything randomly.

Even if this is a super bastard game I'm pretty sure that we aren't playing games where special GAFia celebrities get special roles just for them, because that's against the basic tenets of Mafia as a game. The only remaining reasonable option in my mind is that your whole story is nonsense.

My thoughts as well, although his open breadcrumbing is what bothers me the most because of how blatant it is. If he survived this Night phase, and subsequent phases, people would only increasingly become suspicious of him, leading him to be lynched eventually. LoC's plan just doesn't make sense.

This is such a lazy reason to lynch someone and I know you are better than this. I'm ok with my vote where it is right now. LoC trying to hint as a lost partner is also viable.

There are quite a few people who haven't posted at all. It's a game of 31 people, we aren't going to hit everyone during day 1 talks, it just is what it is.

I mean, sure, if you want to take that out of context then it's odd but you have to see that I was talking about a newbie who seemed confused for some odd reason that the OP didn't spoon feed all of the information about the game to them. I wasn't talking about this game in particular, I was giving out mafia 101 lessons.


Meh, my role was kind of public, I could have played it off like a joke but it was more useful this way.

There have been public roles which haven't been randomly assigned in the past, such as the sheriff in Woof.

Thank god someone else gets it. Nothing adds up with Sorian.

On another note, how on earth does anyone think they can pull a double lynch off? Mafia aren't gonna get trapped in that. You gotta be kidding me. They just refuse to vote for the other person, and then when it is the last minute they add the vote on. You'd have to catch two scum, and even then they'd only let you lynch one.

Really what?

Unless I missed something, I truly don't understand what Sorian's role could possibly even be. The Jesus Resurrection thing did nothing on D1. What's the point of it? Thinking it might not actually be part of his real role doesn't seem that illogical to me.

Like... if I were creating roles why would I create say... this role:

.

What's the point of the die/revive? The meat of the role is access to X/Y/Z.