|
|
Post by Sorian on Jan 8, 2016 22:33:48 GMT -8
Nah, its clear the real reason you want me dead is because you know you can't night kill me. The votes will slowly trickle in as your teammates set up the kill. No. I won't let you. My time is now. Take this!! Vote:ScraftyWhatever you say, luv. I'm certainly not afraid to die; if anything my flip would likely be more useful than any input I can offer at this avenue. My death would aid in establishing some early voting patterns as well, which would be quite nice indeed considering how many of you lot seem to want to rush me to my timely demise. Eh, when the game needs 16 for a majority, I can't really see how there are so many trying to rush you to your demise. What do you have, 2-3 votes right now? |
|
|
|
Post by ridli on Jan 8, 2016 22:33:49 GMT -8
Why would I not just point out the most obvious and concise post that shows exactly how and why I think you're scum? You're consistently acting as a source of disinformation. If I was a towny in your shoes, I probably would have said "nothing happened at all, it was probably a joke". This would have gotten the outcome you CLAIM you want, which is everyone ignoring you and focusing on scum hunting. However, there is a conflict in motive here. You did want to make yourself into a temporary spectacle and make everyone believe you to have special information, which makes me ask "why?". And the answers to that question lead me to believe scum, or that you may have just wanted the attention. There's a possibility it's the former, which is why I'm voting for you. Saying nothing happened doesn't get across the key pieces of information I had to deliver: There are multiple scum factions. Our spirit animals are in groupings, not pairs and not individuals. Don't talk about your spirit animal and treat it like you would treat an important PR. Wouldn't key information, by definition, have been in the OP? |
|
|
|
Post by Sorian on Jan 8, 2016 22:35:29 GMT -8
Saying nothing happened doesn't get across the key pieces of information I had to deliver: There are multiple scum factions. Our spirit animals are in groupings, not pairs and not individuals. Don't talk about your spirit animal and treat it like you would treat an important PR. Wouldn't key information, by definition, have been in the OP? ? No, not in the least. Town has numbers and is at an information disadvantage. Mafia has information is at a numbers disadvantage. That's the key balance to a game of mafia. |
|
|
|
Post by ridli on Jan 8, 2016 22:35:41 GMT -8
I.e. If this is crucial information, why has it been left up to player agency to convey it? Thats a terrible idea.
|
|
|
|
Post by Sorian on Jan 8, 2016 22:36:51 GMT -8
So we're supposed to hunt scum, who are after each other as well, thus not giving us any real connections to follow even if we luck into a lynch? Starting to feel like majority of us are just targets and dont actually get to play a game. Lynch me and Sorian please. Also, why would we be lynching you? Or is that a "get me out of this game" comment? |
|
|
|
Post by LordofCastamere on Jan 8, 2016 22:38:10 GMT -8
Nah, its clear the real reason you want me dead is because you know you can't night kill me. The votes will slowly trickle in as your teammates set up the kill. No. I won't let you. My time is now. Take this!! Vote:ScraftyWhatever you say, luv. I'm certainly not afraid to die; if anything my flip would likely be more useful than any input I can offer at this avenue. My death would aid in establishing some early voting patterns as well, which would be quite nice indeed considering how many of you lot seem to want to rush me to my timely demise. Death is only Step 1 on the path to immortality. |
|
|
|
Post by squidyj on Jan 8, 2016 22:38:44 GMT -8
Man that scrafty defense is suspect as fuck.
|
|
|
|
Post by squidyj on Jan 8, 2016 22:39:01 GMT -8
Also, It's fine LoC, I took a screenshot =D
|
|
|
|
Post by Sorian on Jan 8, 2016 22:39:24 GMT -8
I.e. If this is crucial information, why has it been left up to player agency to convey it? Thats a terrible idea. That's.....every game of mafia ever? Crucial information is always hidden from town. Honestly, the presence of multi-faction scum is sometimes hidden from the scum teams as well so what I said might have been news to them as well. But no, you shouldn't be expecting every important bit of info to be in the OP or your role PM, that's not how it works. |
|
|
|
Post by ridli on Jan 8, 2016 22:39:31 GMT -8
So we're supposed to hunt scum, who are after each other as well, thus not giving us any real connections to follow even if we luck into a lynch? Starting to feel like majority of us are just targets and dont actually get to play a game. Lynch me and Sorian please. Also, why would we be lynching you? Or is that a "get me out of this game" comment? I believe you need to be lynched. You and maybe others think only scum would want that. Ill offer myself up as sacrifice if needed to disprove it. |
|
|
|
Post by Sorian on Jan 8, 2016 22:43:42 GMT -8
Also, why would we be lynching you? Or is that a "get me out of this game" comment? I believe you need to be lynched. You and maybe others think only scum would want that. Ill offer myself up as sacrifice if needed to disprove it. First off, wasting our double lynch today would be worthless. Second, pretending that you are doing something noble by dying with me isn't earning any brownie points. Third, why do you believe I need to be lynched? Do you believe I am scum? Death is only Step 1 on the path to immortality. Hmm |
|
|
|
Post by squidyj on Jan 8, 2016 22:44:12 GMT -8
Why does Sorian need to be lynched?
|
|
|
|
Post by ridli on Jan 8, 2016 22:45:39 GMT -8
To see if his role is why we're being subjected to this, or if its somebody else's whim.
|
|
|
|
Post by LordofCastamere on Jan 8, 2016 22:49:33 GMT -8
Why does Sorian need to be lynched? Killing Sorian is step 1 on the path to pacing. |
|
|
|
Post by Sorian on Jan 8, 2016 22:52:37 GMT -8
To see if his role is why we're being subjected to this, or if its somebody else's whim. So you want to lynch out of convenience as opposed to looking for the evil spirits mixed in with us? Duly noted. -------- I've seen all there is to see out of Darryl for now. I'm still a bit awake and will probably respond for a bit but I'll park my vote on an inactive for the night. Tim's absence seems the most out of character. VOTE: CzarTim |
|
|
|
Post by Bombay on Jan 8, 2016 23:14:09 GMT -8
I.e. If this is crucial information, why has it been left up to player agency to convey it? Thats a terrible idea. That's.....every game of mafia ever? Crucial information is always hidden from town. Honestly, the presence of multi-faction scum is sometimes hidden from the scum teams as well so what I said might have been news to them as well. But no, you shouldn't be expecting every important bit of info to be in the OP or your role PM, that's not how it works. "Crucial information" is instead to be delivered by a player who is "killed" for breaking a rule in the OP and "resurrected", under the pretense that he cannot say anything whatsoever, period, and btw, everything he said is already skirting that line so don't ask for any more info. Like, what the fuck? I'm scummy for finding this suspect? |
|
|
|
Post by Sorian on Jan 8, 2016 23:20:53 GMT -8
That's.....every game of mafia ever? Crucial information is always hidden from town. Honestly, the presence of multi-faction scum is sometimes hidden from the scum teams as well so what I said might have been news to them as well. But no, you shouldn't be expecting every important bit of info to be in the OP or your role PM, that's not how it works. "Crucial information" is instead to be delivered by a player who is "killed" for breaking a rule in the OP and "resurrected", under the pretense that he cannot say anything whatsoever, period, and btw, everything he said is already skirting that line so don't ask for any more info. Like, what the fuck? I'm scummy for finding this suspect? Information comes from many sources. I just can't talk about how my power interacts with things that are not visible to this thread. Simple as that Darryl. Can I at least ask what your thoughts are on other topics? We do this song and dance every single time, let's start preparing for one of us to flip as town so that we can be a step ahead this time. Do you have no interest in the Scrafty or LoC situations? And no, I'm not trying to change the subject, whether you are right or wrong about me, tunneling is going to lead to less information overall. We're at day 1, just raw odds say you are going to be wrong, I'd prefer to have one of the more logical thinkers branching out and not sitting here beating a dead horse. |
|
|
|
Post by nin1000 on Jan 8, 2016 23:32:02 GMT -8
Why does Sorian need to be lynched? Killing Sorian is step 1 on the path to pacing. i agree |
|
|
|
Post by Bombay on Jan 8, 2016 23:44:13 GMT -8
"Crucial information" is instead to be delivered by a player who is "killed" for breaking a rule in the OP and "resurrected", under the pretense that he cannot say anything whatsoever, period, and btw, everything he said is already skirting that line so don't ask for any more info. Like, what the fuck? I'm scummy for finding this suspect? Information comes from many sources. I just can't talk about how my power interacts with things that are not visible to this thread. Simple as that Darryl. Can I at least ask what your thoughts are on other topics? We do this song and dance every single time, let's start preparing for one of us to flip as town so that we can be a step ahead this time. Do you have no interest in the Scrafty or LoC situations? And no, I'm not trying to change the subject, whether you are right or wrong about me, tunneling is going to lead to less information overall. We're at day 1, just raw odds say you are going to be wrong, I'd prefer to have one of the more logical thinkers branching out and not sitting here beating a dead horse. Maybe you should stop being so scummy, then. You did your stupid opening post, then came back and did essentially another opening post. Going from "don't reveal your PRs", to "don't reveal your spirit animals.". I don't like the LoC vs Scrafty thing because they're both posting like they're acting. I'm not touching that weird shit right now. I have: 100% Scum: Cabot Roytheone Sorian Nin1000 |
|
|
|
Post by LordofCastamere on Jan 8, 2016 23:48:18 GMT -8
Good. Let's all bandwagon Sorian.
|
|
|
|
Post by Sorian on Jan 8, 2016 23:51:05 GMT -8
Information comes from many sources. I just can't talk about how my power interacts with things that are not visible to this thread. Simple as that Darryl. Can I at least ask what your thoughts are on other topics? We do this song and dance every single time, let's start preparing for one of us to flip as town so that we can be a step ahead this time. Do you have no interest in the Scrafty or LoC situations? And no, I'm not trying to change the subject, whether you are right or wrong about me, tunneling is going to lead to less information overall. We're at day 1, just raw odds say you are going to be wrong, I'd prefer to have one of the more logical thinkers branching out and not sitting here beating a dead horse. Maybe you should stop being so scummy, then. You did your stupid opening post, then came back and did essentially another opening post. Going from "don't reveal your PRs", to "don't reveal your spirit animals.". I don't like the LoC vs Scrafty thing because they're both posting like they're acting. I'm not touching that weird shit right now. I have: 100% Scum: Cabot Roytheone Sorian Nin1000 Oh? You going to explain the logic on the rest of those. # sickshitreads |
|
|
|
Post by Bombay on Jan 9, 2016 0:02:56 GMT -8
Maybe you should stop being so scummy, then. You did your stupid opening post, then came back and did essentially another opening post. Going from "don't reveal your PRs", to "don't reveal your spirit animals.". I don't like the LoC vs Scrafty thing because they're both posting like they're acting. I'm not touching that weird shit right now. I have: 100% Scum: Cabot Roytheone Sorian Nin1000 Oh? You going to explain the logic on the rest of those. # sickshitreads Nice. I'm glad you were only interested in my opinions on other people simply to remove the heat off you. |
|
|
|
Post by nin1000 on Jan 9, 2016 0:03:37 GMT -8
Information comes from many sources. I just can't talk about how my power interacts with things that are not visible to this thread. Simple as that Darryl. Can I at least ask what your thoughts are on other topics? We do this song and dance every single time, let's start preparing for one of us to flip as town so that we can be a step ahead this time. Do you have no interest in the Scrafty or LoC situations? And no, I'm not trying to change the subject, whether you are right or wrong about me, tunneling is going to lead to less information overall. We're at day 1, just raw odds say you are going to be wrong, I'd prefer to have one of the more logical thinkers branching out and not sitting here beating a dead horse. Maybe you should stop being so scummy, then. You did your stupid opening post, then came back and did essentially another opening post. Going from "don't reveal your PRs", to "don't reveal your spirit animals.". I don't like the LoC vs Scrafty thing because they're both posting like they're acting. I'm not touching that weird shit right now. I have: 100% Scum: Cabot Roytheone Sorian Nin1000  |
|
|
|
Post by Bombay on Jan 9, 2016 0:09:09 GMT -8
Someone call me scum so I can respond in a gif
|
|
|
|
Post by nin1000 on Jan 9, 2016 0:12:56 GMT -8
Someone call me scum so I can respond in a gif i dnot have any beef with you my asian friend. Since we both are asians i think we should put our hatred aside and start playing. Dont wory if you call me scum its ok. I dont mind that since it is not my first game. Have a nice day |
|
|
|
Post by squidyj on Jan 9, 2016 1:17:26 GMT -8
Yeah I'm definitely leaning not-town on Bombarryl but I feel like if we give himself a day or two he'll just hang himself further and we can be more sure about it.
|
|
|
|
Post by nin1000 on Jan 9, 2016 1:43:44 GMT -8
Yeah I'm definitely leaning not-town on Bombarryl but I feel like if we give himself a day or two he'll just hang himself further and we can be more sure about it. Since i know Asian culture i know aswell that he is playing as he used to play. He is annoying for sure but i dont feel that bad about him right now. Of course my eyes will be open for him in the following days.  |
|
|
|
Post by Roytheone on Jan 9, 2016 2:46:05 GMT -8
Is there any way to filter out the posts of a single user? Just wondering. Everyone is just ignoring this? Don't worry squidyj, I will be your knight in not so shiny armor because polishing my armor takes way too long! If you press the magnifying glass to the right of the search box, you can search the thread by "post created by". It works quite nicely, better even than gaf where you only get like three lines of every post and have to click on them to see the full post. That sucks. Also, I am still against lynching Sorian today. He has given us a lot of information that will be easy to check (there are multiple scum teams, spirit buddies are in groups, the day 9 thing isn't important), so why waste a lynch to check those if we can just wait and see in order to check his info? Darryl seems to be his normal self, trowing accusations around and pretending that he is 100 % sure about them. Thats how town Darryl plays and how Scum darryl plays, so not much there to go on. BTW, I have reasons to believe that the roles we got are not 100 % RNG'd, and that splinter did some things to achieve maximum amusement. That's maximum amusement for him and not for us mind you! So if you are asking yourself "did splinter did this to make it more funny?", the answer could very well be: yes. |
|
|
|
Post by cabot on Jan 9, 2016 2:51:08 GMT -8
I go get dinner and start packing up my hut and I see that you all have gone crazy! Seriously, we need to sacrifice someone to the blood God of the volcano (may it ever be merciful in its destruction). I agree with Sorian, a random poster who seems to have just checked in (even I satisfy that requirement), that's who we should go after. I'm not voting for any major poster today (no Sorian, Bombay/daryll for example). I don't really want to vote for the following because they are entertaining nin1000, blarg and scraftydevil So you've just given up on scum hunting? Stinks. VOTE: zippedpinheadYou'll do for now. You take one little day nap and wake up to like 500 posts. Xam is fluffy, but it seems to me to be more of the redhood variety than scum. Not really too suspicious of him as is. Sorian being Sorian. Don't think lynching him is the right move at this time. LoC definitely making himself big and loud. Glad to see Blarg is here so I expect 30 pages by tomorrow. And that I'll give his posts/opinions more serious consideration following HP. Sorry this is kind of token activity ish. Was asleep for most of the day and have a friend to pick up at the airport. More meaningful contributions tomorrow. Probably won't be putting my vote on xam though. Double vote I think is useful to town until it's not (close to lylo). I think waiting for N1 and the amount of chaos/carnage in addition to any flips is a good idea. Id rather use it early to get lore information and get us to mid game status quicker. Kawl has posted a couple more after this, but this is the memorable one, and I dont much care for it. Can you say Sorian being Sorian when this is a pretty different situation from other games? He's 'died' and come back again, and claims to have important information for town regarding spirit animals. That's absolutely not standard Sorian. His point on Xam if fair, and he agreed with CB's point of taking down weak players early, which again I can see as a valid conclusion. Should we completely give up the scumhunt just to do this, though? Maybe as a last resort, considering it now seems not very productive. Others: Sorian - Don't know what to make of the death thing, but I don't read scum so far Darryl - He's wrong on my read, so he's probably wrong on most things right now. The Palmer PM Gaff - I didn't like this at all, the people that were trying to make a bigger deal of this. Classic thing for a scum to hide in, pretending he or she is proactive. I'll go back to this to get the involved parties but my slightly hungover head tells me LoC was in there? squidy - nothing out of the ordinary here yet. Blarg - Doing his usual stuff, no read ridli - Seems to be a little weird on the last page, but I'm not reading that as scum currently. Scrafty - Uncertain. roy - Seems about what I expect so far, but we all know that's the problem. What I expect from roy can easily be town or scum. Can others give me some feedback on roy so far? Swamped - I'm not getting good vibes currently, but this happened in woof 2 as well. I just don't read swamped effectively at all. ultron - I've liked ultron so far. Kalor - The slip was silly, but slips aren't scumtells. Nothing he's done since has raised alarm bells. Waiting for more contributions from Tim Launch L_P Pop Terra Going from just reading the last few pages I don't remember seeing much of these guys. |
|
|
|
Post by cabot on Jan 9, 2016 3:09:17 GMT -8
Scratch my link of LoC to the Palmer thing, that was Ty.
It wasn't as bad as I remember, he seemed to have missed it happening, still think questioning the reasoning seemed pretty pointless though.
|
|
