That's what I'm saying though, your only contributions up to that point were pointing out obvious ways people (mostly me) stand out, hence asking if anything else had caught your eye. I'm not saying you created a narrative, I'm saying that you're making really shallow obvious observations and then patting yourself on the back for it because you brought something up that no one else was talking about.
There's some debate about Blarg tells earlier in this thread.
Scum's roles (especially ninja and strongkill) also hint quite strongly at there being more town roles remaning unless they're not countering anything. Strongman could also be made to kill the neutral who presumably is bulletproof.
Post by Barrylocke on Sept 30, 2016 5:28:51 GMT -8
Splinter suggests that salva just plays blegh in general when he's town. The only other game in recent time I've played with Salva was Bar mafia where he was town...and unhelpful. So maybe there's something to that?
Post by Barrylocke on Sept 30, 2016 14:00:14 GMT -8
It really is strange that a serial killer type role isn't even given much consideration.
Sawneeks is my game mvp candidate. She has been nailing the being involved and appearing helpful thing from day 1. I almost think that her seperation from the rest of the mafia has only helped her with that.
Hmm, I haven't given that much thought. One curious thing is he brought up the second kill a lot for a serial killer and that's a lot of counters for the poor tracker. Dunno who else it could be. Maybe Ynnek, but just because I don't think much about him.
Verelios seems to speak as if he's part of a team. Maybe just more aware of the flips.
Wow, they seriously did it... Salva played his last three games exactly the same and was mislynched twice for it (in bar he was killed)
Let's have a look at the reasoning this time:
Dusk: ... Fire: Don't like that people defend him. Verelios: Lynch inactives Sawneeks: Vote record, people defending him. Nin: ... Starsketch: ... UnmaskedFerret: Do we still have a tie? Blarg: CAPSLOCK
Wow. That's why we deserve to lose this game.
What's up with this game? Town (me included of course) has been struggling from the get go and never caught onto anything...
Of course we have three low activity scum players LP, Fire and Roy ~ hard to filter out in between the other low activity players ~ but Blarg is all over the place. He truly got his meta right, he can do what he wants. Sawneeks is MVP, false town leader.
Let me rephrase it: at which point in the game should we have done something different? Where could town begin to hunt scum? What is the problem here and how could one resolve it?
Town is not making any effort right now. Royal, Goddamn and now Salva were all lynched in a sense of apathy and dis-interest from town. It's basically the perfect playground for scum, they can do anything right now.
Last Edit: Oct 1, 2016 12:30:32 GMT -8 by Burbeting