*Splinter will have an uphill battle arguing for me at this point: I was right and he fought that vigorously.
I think StarSketch could be an easy low-activity target. Faddy is up there in votes, even if I actually feel bad about it. I did not realize this was his first game. I would love to think we could get a train going on *Splinter, but at this point I am not in a position to be combing posts looking for dirt.
Well, I would have preferred seeing Faddy bite it for 2 kills in 1 day... At least the newbie gets to live some more.
And let's not NK because of personal reasons that are ultimately meaningless to the actual game. We should go for the best kill.
I still think *Splinter is the best NK for tactical reasons also. It gives Bronx and I the wifom "that would be too suspicious" out. Ty40n town or null reads most of us, so for now between the two of them he should stay.
Or we go for someone else entirely, but I think that's riskier.
I don't think any of us really messed up, but it was looking a bit negative for Bronx near the end. You probably went too hard on blaming people for Terra's suicide when they wouldn't be able to have known anything about him.
And sure, I'm fine with it if Splinter's the best choice.
Who to roleblock? Who to FA investigate? Who to kill? Who should do it/should it be a strongman?
Personally I think we should roleblock someone that was being cagey about their FA maybe? Really not sure who to go for. Maybe Sorian if we assume he has a PR due to his FA.
I know the previous idea was Sorian for the FA but I thought of something. If you get either seen doing it or are forced to claim at some point wouldn't it make more sense for you to investigate someone a townie would? Like Kark for his claim, Faddy for his weirdness, maybe even Blarg, OA, or nin. I'm not sure town would investigate Sorian in this situation. Or you could pick someone you were fake suspicious of in the thread.
I think I'm fine with a Splinter kill but I think it's going to cause more headaches for Bronx.
Re: Roleblock. Flush was the first to suggest that FA may give away certain PRs. It is possible he made that suggestion because he has a PR limited by his FA. Might be a good option for either the role block or my FA-cop.
I still think Sorian is a good option for my FA-cop; we will either find out he is lying or we will find out what his time limit is. Knowing if Kark is lying could also be a good use.
It's your power, if you feel you could justify checking Sorian then go for it. I think Royal is a PR but I'm not certain it's a useful one. I need to go back and see if there's any weird interactions between him and Ty. The way Ty was so sure he was Town made me wonder if they're masons or something.
I think you're right that avoiding Sorian for at least tonight is probably best. Anyone Watching will probably go there. Then again, we avoided Sorian N1 as scum in Zelda figuring the doctor would go that way; Bronx ending up killing Doctor Sorian!
I'm not too concerned if you get seen visiting since you have a good claim that can't even be interrupted by the alignment cop now. It's more whether you feel comfortable arguing why your Town self would investigate him over someone else.
Looking through the thread I'm pretty sure Kark's FA is voting. I didn't see a vote he made at least.
I think we should roleblock Kark or Sorian.
I think we should FA check whoever AB would be okay clearing as town in the future (if they are alive at that point). Once one of us flips anyone he says the FA of will be cleared as town because all but Flux's FA makes it obvious we're scum.
I think we should kill Splinter with a strongman kill via Bronx. If we want to save the strong kills we should kill someone a bit less prevalent like kingkitty and do it either via Bronx or Flux.
Also if Blarg was in any way telling the truth he copied Faddy, something to keep in mind.
You're right, Karkador did not vote once. That is possibly his FA; I'm not sure how he has been in previous games and if he has skipped voting like that before.
1. I'm for role blocking Sorian. 2. I'm okay for FA investigating anyone who hasn't claimed theirs or is Blarg. 3. I guess I'm okay with killing Splinter, but I'm not too into wasting a strongman kill when it's our very first night phase.
I will block Sorian though barring further arguments. I mainly worry since we're attacking one of I would say three likely targets for protection. You're right though it'll probably be fine. Part of it is just my fear that town is going to randomly lynch Bronx early on just because half the players seem apt to kill him just because it's Bronx lol