|
|
Post by Sawneeks on Jan 13, 2016 20:01:29 GMT -8
I'm not sold on scrafty, and I really don't want Sorian here (especially since I think he will get lynched tomorrow). If Sorian is still alive after tomorrow, I think he is a good night candidate for night 11. Cabot, dusk, czartim, Terrabyte, and Cornb. Those are the people I think are the most scummy. I will gladly vote for any of them from a "might be scum" point of view. In fact, vote: Cornb Just for dropping the hammer on Ridli, at least I think he did. Out of those names the only one I might be willing to vote out is Dusk or Cabot but I would need to read over their posts once more. I keep seeing Cabot's name brought up both here and the main thread for being 'Scum' but I never see any reasons as to why people think that is. What has he done that's Scummy?? Also Corn was the one who finally hammered Ridli in the end and that's part of the reason why I think he is Town lol. No way Scum was going to bring that much attention by hammering a Townie, that's way too risky. I'm putting Corn in the 'misguided Town' file. |
|
|
|
Post by zippedpinhead on Jan 13, 2016 20:29:30 GMT -8
I'm not sold on scrafty, and I really don't want Sorian here (especially since I think he will get lynched tomorrow). If Sorian is still alive after tomorrow, I think he is a good night candidate for night 11. Cabot, dusk, czartim, Terrabyte, and Cornb. Those are the people I think are the most scummy. I will gladly vote for any of them from a "might be scum" point of view. In fact, vote: Cornb Just for dropping the hammer on Ridli, at least I think he did. Out of those names the only one I might be willing to vote out is Dusk or Cabot but I would need to read over their posts once more. I keep seeing Cabot's name brought up both here and the main thread for being 'Scum' but I never see any reasons as to why people think that is. What has he done that's Scummy?? Also Corn was the one who finally hammered Ridli in the end and that's part of the reason why I think he is Town lol. No way Scum was going to bring that much attention by hammering a Townie, that's way too risky. I'm putting Corn in the 'misguided Town' file. I put Cabot on my list because he was the first vote for me on the island (twice) I disagree on scum finally dropping the hammer, especially if it's close to the end of the day. It's not against a scum philosophy to try and limit conversation, and if people make the decision to vote someone, and then conversation starts to drift, I see scum putting the nail in the coffin. Cornb is also in the same boat as czartim, they are slightly scummy in their play BUT they are really good at scum finding when they are town and could benefit us. This game has so many levels... |
|
|
|
Post by Sawneeks on Jan 13, 2016 20:32:31 GMT -8
If we're doing Top Scum:
-Nin1000. Just went over his posts and there is a whole lot of talk with no substance at all. There are maybe 3 good posts he has done so far and he stayed away from the Ridli discussion, although that might just be timezone differences.
-ScraftyDevil. Been a big push for her lynch since Day 1 and, while I've eased up slightly on my read, I still want answers. Her Day 1 activity is full of blendy posts and 'middle of the road' opinions so as to not step on anyone's toes. When I questioned her she would respond to them by simply repeating what she said in different words, not fully answering those questions at all. She then dropped off on the questions rather suddenly and never came around to them again, something I know Scum do when they believe the suspicion won't gain traction. I believe it was Roy or Hyper who suggested Exo do that in HP Mafia when I nailed him as Scum in a read. She has definitely picked up more today and is less blendy but her votes are still safe and she is flowing with the crowd much more than I would like.
-Ultron87. More of a coasting player but notably absent from L_P's list which already contained 2 other low-count players. He is paying attention enough to make a sparse post here and there but he isn't actively engaged anywhere. He also switched votes last minute on Day 1 for no reason.
-Xamtheking. L_P's 'Town' read. Went over his posts in brief and noticed he was surprisingly absent for this Days end shenanigans. He is one of the earliest votes on Ridli, harping Sorian's 'you're too experienced to be new' reasoning, and then doesn't comment much on the rest of the proceedings even though he was around and posting fluff.
-Squidyj. Twice in a row he votes for people he believes are Town but 'doesn't see the vote switching' so he goes in anyway. Maybe not Scum but definitely not Pro-Town either lol.
After going through a couple people I honestly feel it would be easier to list who I don't think is Scummy lol. Everyone is suspicious right now.
|
|
|
|
Post by Sawneeks on Jan 13, 2016 20:38:30 GMT -8
Out of those names the only one I might be willing to vote out is Dusk or Cabot but I would need to read over their posts once more. I keep seeing Cabot's name brought up both here and the main thread for being 'Scum' but I never see any reasons as to why people think that is. What has he done that's Scummy?? Also Corn was the one who finally hammered Ridli in the end and that's part of the reason why I think he is Town lol. No way Scum was going to bring that much attention by hammering a Townie, that's way too risky. I'm putting Corn in the 'misguided Town' file. I put Cabot on my list because he was the first vote for me on the island (twice) I disagree on scum finally dropping the hammer, especially if it's close to the end of the day. It's not against a scum philosophy to try and limit conversation, and if people make the decision to vote someone, and then conversation starts to drift, I see scum putting the nail in the coffin. Cornb is also in the same boat as czartim, they are slightly scummy in their play BUT they are really good at scum finding when they are town and could benefit us. This game has so many levels... So Cabot is your OMGUS scum? I can see that happening near the end of the game but not this early. There were already a few people suspicious of Corn before this, after that mishap he's going to have a couple people tomorrow asking him what the hell he was doing. Either way he is going to have people going after him tomorrow, same with Sorian and it's why I'm wary to kill either right now. If Sorian does end up living until the next Night I agree we should heavily consider bringing him here though. |
|
|
|
Post by zippedpinhead on Jan 13, 2016 20:52:32 GMT -8
I put Cabot on my list because he was the first vote for me on the island (twice) I disagree on scum finally dropping the hammer, especially if it's close to the end of the day. It's not against a scum philosophy to try and limit conversation, and if people make the decision to vote someone, and then conversation starts to drift, I see scum putting the nail in the coffin. Cornb is also in the same boat as czartim, they are slightly scummy in their play BUT they are really good at scum finding when they are town and could benefit us. This game has so many levels... So Cabot is your OMGUS scum? I can see that happening near the end of the game but not this early. There were already a few people suspicious of Corn before this, after that mishap he's going to have a couple people tomorrow asking him what the hell he was doing. Either way he is going to have people going after him tomorrow, same with Sorian and it's why I'm wary to kill either right now. If Sorian does end up living until the next Night I agree we should heavily consider bringing him here though. Cabot? Hardly, more a revenge thing at this point. Being able to night kill people that voted you out is tempting. Our simple humanity. I can see that about Cornb, and if we do let him live he will have to own up for his actions. The rest of your reads are great, only one I really disagree with is Xam, this Xam feels a lot more like Woof Xam and not Final Fantasy Xam. A bit metagamey but it's what my gut is saying. |
|
|
|
Post by Roytheone on Jan 14, 2016 3:19:46 GMT -8
Things to say:
- Thought about it some more, and getting as much people to believe in me because they got bestowed is probably very useful, so probably don't bestow on me. Unless you bestow investigation or kill powers, since those could be a danger to me in the wrong hands. Direct powers are still welcome though!
- I agree with squidward that 6 deaths is unlikely, I would guess 1 kill from you guys, 1 kill from a town PR and 1 kill from scum. No idea how that scum kill will work though since L_P his role pm didn't say anything about that.
- The kill everyone line is interesting. Could hint to neutrals, or the second scum team Sorian claims there is.
- We could get in a situation where there is only town on the island left, and we will slowly start to murder eachother while you guys have a time limit to banish the remaining scum. Good luck if that happens.
- Both the afterlife night lynch and the island day lynch being very successful in hitting scum would increase the scum presence here, making it more important to hit scum during the banish vote. A scum majority in here would give them control of the night kill, not good.
- People I would be ok with getting killed: Xam, Scrafty, Dusk and Cabot (#crashoftheOTP). I think I may even prefer Cabby since A) he is very suspect of me and B) he isn't really suspect in anyone else his eyes. For tomorrow, preventing me from becoming a lynch target is probably a good goal to have, so having a couple of suspect people around will help with that. If I am forced to claim, better for me to claim with as much information and flips as possible.
|
|
|
|
Post by Roytheone on Jan 14, 2016 3:55:51 GMT -8
Actually, don't kill scrafty. A lot of people seemed to be suspect of me and scrafty for surviving while soft claiming. If Scrafty now dies and i live, that could be bad.
|
|
|
|
Post by ridli on Jan 14, 2016 6:25:46 GMT -8
Roy, can you wait 24 hours to claim? I want to see what shakes loose first.
|
|
|
|
Post by Roytheone on Jan 14, 2016 7:52:13 GMT -8
Roy, can you wait 24 hours to claim? I want to see what shakes loose first. I am not going to claim if not needed. But if it turns out I was investigated, I will claim immediately. |
|
|
|
Post by zippedpinhead on Jan 14, 2016 7:52:31 GMT -8
Am I the only person with a vote cast tonight?
|
|
|
|
Post by Swamped on Jan 14, 2016 8:20:43 GMT -8
Oh dear, deadline is today right? Let me take a shower first...
|
|
|
|
Post by Swamped on Jan 14, 2016 8:25:25 GMT -8
VOTE: Nin1000
...we are so not getting a consensus huh. I should be around near the deadline to discuss and change votes if necessary. I should reread Corn, but from memory i felt he was town. Sorian is another good kill i could get behind.
|
|
|
|
Post by ridli on Jan 14, 2016 8:31:25 GMT -8
Am I the only person with a vote cast tonight? I voted sorian in the first post. I think its now 3 way tie. I think its a waste to kill Nin. If we have a vig power out there, hes a very likely target. Cornb i'm more neutral on. I don't see his hammer as particularly suspicious. |
|
|
|
Post by Swamped on Jan 14, 2016 8:34:42 GMT -8
^ that's a good point ridli. And is likely he'll get voted out anyhow.
Ok, let's play with fire
VOTE: Sorian
|
|
|
|
Post by Roytheone on Jan 14, 2016 8:37:53 GMT -8
Yeah, you guys should defiantly be a bit more active with this vote business. No offense, but when I die, you guys (well, it would be we then of course ;)will be the only people that will have alignment flips, which makes your scum hunting a lot more important than on the island where they are just running around in the dark.
|
|
|
|
Post by Kalor on Jan 14, 2016 8:40:22 GMT -8
I'm going to vote for nin for now. He sticks out in how he's avoided talking about some topics, such as ridli but yet is active. He feels like he might be scum trying to appear active, not wanting to say anything too controversial.
Vote: nin1000
|
|
|
|
Post by Roytheone on Jan 14, 2016 8:52:43 GMT -8
Well, off to work, may not be back before the deadline so have fun deciding who to drag to hell. Just be sure to at least leave some controversial figures alive so that they can take attention away from me if needed.
Also, be sure to think about what you can give me if I need to claim. Everything that can help is welcome, facts like who got bestowed with what are of course the best, but as simple as a post I copy that sounds like something one of you would say could already help. Hopefully we don't need it, but have it at the ready.
|
|
|
|
Post by zippedpinhead on Jan 14, 2016 8:55:02 GMT -8
If I can get behind a nin1000 vote, he seems active enough (at least after FF ended) but I don't find his posts actually add anything.
vote: nin1000
|
|
|
|
Post by Hyperactivity on Jan 14, 2016 9:17:25 GMT -8
I'm getting replaced soon, but I'd like to remind people that whoever we kill, town might make the mistake assuming scum went after them and that they were innocent, affecting reads for the day
be careful
Vote: Sorian
|
|
|
|
Post by Splinter on Jan 14, 2016 9:30:33 GMT -8
|
|
|
|
Post by Blargonaut on Jan 14, 2016 9:37:31 GMT -8
yo all
I'm sorry I haven't checked in recently, had to finalize Burb's Love Boat Mafia logo before S5 rolled out
...I mean, priorities, amirite
ANYWAY, despite the absence of my promised tome, I choose to-
VOTE: Sorian
because I want Valhalla, not Heaven
|
|
|
|
Post by zippedpinhead on Jan 14, 2016 9:44:12 GMT -8
yo all I'm sorry I haven't checked in recently, had to finalize Burb's Love Boat Mafia logo before S5 rolled out ...I mean, priorities, amirite ANYWAY, despite the absence of my promised tome, I choose to- VOTE: Sorianbecause I want Valhalla, not Heaven I don't know that kill may turn this into jotunheim. |
|
|
|
Post by Splinter on Jan 14, 2016 9:44:34 GMT -8
Thats 4 for Sorian, 6 is a majority
|
|
|
|
Post by Splinter on Jan 14, 2016 9:45:24 GMT -8
Also Hyper is indeed being replaced at the end of this phase (~3 hours)
|
|
|
|
Post by Sawneeks on Jan 14, 2016 9:48:55 GMT -8
I'm leaning towards Sorian only because if we somehow messed up he might actually be able to come back to life. However, I also think he will be a target tonight and after his huge push for Ridli he is also a target in the main thread as well and will most likely be a topic of discussion ( along with Cornbro, Scrafty/Roy, and Ridli's flip ). Nin I can get behind though. Relatively in the background and not a major player in any way. I'm getting replaced soon, but I'd like to remind people that whoever we kill, town might make the mistake assuming scum went after them and that they were innocent, affecting reads for the day be careful Vote: Sorian ;________; |
|
|
|
Post by zippedpinhead on Jan 14, 2016 9:58:52 GMT -8
Majority is 6 today, so same as last day phase.
I really don't want Sorian in the afterlife, but you are all making a very compelling case for him.
I'll hold on my nin1000 vote for now. I'll give it another hour and see where our heads are.
|
|
|
|
Post by MagnumBoy20xx on Jan 14, 2016 10:01:53 GMT -8
Hey,sorry about being in active. I...kinda. Sorta... Forgot that I had subbed into the game until this morning. PLEASEDON'TKILLME,I'LLBEMOREACTIVENOW!
*cough* anyways since I haven't been in the game long enough to get any solid reads, I don't feel comfortable voting to kill someone yet. So whoever you guys decide to bring in here is fine by me.(which looks like Sorain at the moment,that's good for keeping up with the main thread,but this one however...)
Also, good job with lynching L_P! That's one less scum to worry about.
|
|
|
|
Post by Sawneeks on Jan 14, 2016 10:03:01 GMT -8
Majority is 6 today, so same as last day phase. I really don't want Sorian in the afterlife, but you are all making a very compelling case for him. I'll hold on my nin1000 vote for now. I'll give it another hour and see where our heads are. What? No they aren't lol. Almost all of the Sorian voters just kind of put a vote down and didn't explain why. Swamped: 'Let's play with fire'. Nooo explanation on switch. Blarg: 'Valhalla > Heaven'. No explanation Hyper: 'Be careful who we kill because Town can take it the wrong way.' Doesn't explain why he picked Sorian then. |
|
|
|
Post by Blargonaut on Jan 14, 2016 10:12:37 GMT -8
Many times have we met on the field of battle
He gave me this scar on my corporeal form
I desire to engage him in vainglorious combat for all eternity
Kept at sharp arm's length forevermore
|
|
|
|
Post by ridli on Jan 14, 2016 10:12:59 GMT -8
Lot of them have posted reasons previously but yeah, im a bit worried about how this is going. There wasnt much activity tonight.
|
|
.png)
