|
Post by TheExodu5 on Nov 17, 2015 11:16:37 GMT -8
Juuuust putting this out there. Is there a possibility that Snape can read this thread? I'd assume there would be heavy restrictions in place in the case that he can.
In the books he's a double agent and feeds information back to Dumbledore. He also uses veritaserum to force people to tell the truth.
Honestly, I would actually consider killing him. I don't really expect him to be a simple miller if we have 7 Death Eater aligned players.
On one hand, people might still mistrust him. On the other hand, people might actually rally around him and trust him implicitly.
Then again, if he did have a strong power, he might not have put himself in the spotlight day 1.
|
|
|
Post by Roytheone on Nov 17, 2015 12:54:55 GMT -8
So what's the consensus on Blarg? It is a good point that he could be being watched. Right now it sounds like we're leaning investigate Blarg and Voldy check Kalor I don't think it is that much of a problem if someone is watching Blarg when one of you guys visit him. Blarg will (probably) not die that night, so they will not immediately conclude you are scum. It may make your role claim a bit harder to do tough. Juuuust putting this out there. Is there a possibility that Snape can read this thread? I'd assume there would be heavy restrictions in place in the case that he can.
In the books he's a double agent and feeds information back to Dumbledore. He also uses veritaserum to force people to tell the truth.
Honestly, I would actually consider killing him. I don't really expect him to be a simple miller if we have 7 Death Eater aligned players.
On one hand, people might still mistrust him. On the other hand, people might actually rally around him and trust him implicitly.
Then again, if he did have a strong power, he might not have put himself in the spotlight day 1. I agree with you that we shouldn't take Burb his miller claim as truth. Miller's tend to not be NK by scum, so if you are confident that you can talk yourself out of being lynched by town, it is a good way to try to keep yourself safe as a strong PR. We should keep a close eye on Burb, but I don't think we have to target him with anything....yet.
|
|
|
Post by LordofCastamere on Nov 17, 2015 14:53:53 GMT -8
What would we even gain by hitting Blarg? He's the most active player in the game, besides hyper. He hasn't pissed of many town players. Theres a good chance someone targets him. Unless your damn sure he's V, but he looks to be playing a town oriented game right now. I say its too risky.
|
|
|
Post by Roytheone on Nov 17, 2015 15:25:59 GMT -8
What would we even gain by hitting Blarg? He's the most active player in the game, besides hyper. He hasn't pissed of many town players. Theres a good chance someone targets him. Unless your damn sure he's V, but he looks to be playing a town oriented game right now. I say its too risky. Blarg is a very special kind of player. People WILL get fed up with him eventually, and when that happens I sure as hell want to know if he is on our side or not. Also, the risk isn't that high. A watcher will see hyper or arkos visit him, sure, but to immediately assume they are scum would be a ridiculous leap in logic.
|
|
|
Post by LordofCastamere on Nov 17, 2015 17:04:30 GMT -8
They're not gonna get fed up with him tomorrow. Especially with "Blarg lynching" turning into a scum tell. I see no reason to rush this. Unessceary risk.
Again I say low activity tonight, high activity tomorrow. -- Hm, wait. "Solid." Blarg used that word in his last reasoning post with add emphasis. His first post was sneak, sneak = Solid Snake. What if Blarg is a neutral Bastille, or one of the Creevey brothers? Colin Creevey as a peeping tom is pretty damn good. Or, Oh shit. What if he attacks anyone that targets him? Look at him during the night and poof stone.
I think changed my mind. Role hit him. If he's town, Mr Bastillie is getting lynched tomorrow.
|
|
|
Post by Hyperactivity on Nov 17, 2015 17:42:30 GMT -8
So does
kill: Swamped/Matt Attack RB: MA/Swamped Investigate: Blargonaut
sound good?
Now what about Arkos
I went through RetroMG's posts in cthulhu day 1 where he tried to be recruited, seemed like the main thing would be that he referenced how he was insane and a post where he said he'd rather be claimed by cultiests than lynched
Gonna go through how Darryl acted now in Animal Crossing, and then BananaSpacePrincess in Election
|
|
|
Post by TheExodu5 on Nov 17, 2015 18:30:11 GMT -8
Sawneeks has been bitten. Poison courses through her veins.
|
|
|
Post by Retro on Nov 17, 2015 18:41:30 GMT -8
I went through RetroMG's posts in cthulhu day 1 where he tried to be recruited, seemed like the main thing would be that he referenced how he was insane and a post where he said he'd rather be claimed by cultiests than lynched Gonna go through how Darryl acted now in Animal Crossing, and then BananaSpacePrincess in Election Yeah, you remember how well my efforts to be recruited went.
|
|
|
Post by Roytheone on Nov 17, 2015 23:36:00 GMT -8
So we are now well past half of the night phase and have yet to hear a single thing from crab. Hell, he have said a total of 5 words in this thread! Salva/Nin, can he be proded?
|
|
|
Post by nin1000 on Nov 18, 2015 1:04:57 GMT -8
So we are now well past half of the night phase and have yet to hear a single thing from crab. Hell, he have said a total of 5 words in this thread! Salva/Nin, can he be proded? A pm has been send
|
|
|
Post by Roytheone on Nov 18, 2015 2:10:03 GMT -8
Thanks Nin! Hopefully crab didn't forgot he can still post here even when he is banned. They're not gonna get fed up with him tomorrow. Especially with "Blarg lynching" turning into a scum tell. I see no reason to rush this. Unessceary risk. Again I say low activity tonight, high activity tomorrow. -- Hm, wait. "Solid." Blarg used that word in his last reasoning post with add emphasis. His first post was sneak, sneak = Solid Snake. What if Blarg is a neutral Bastille, or one of the Creevey brothers? Colin Creevey as a peeping tom is pretty damn good. Or, Oh shit. What if he attacks anyone that targets him? Look at him during the night and poof stone. I think changed my mind. Role hit him. If he's town, Mr Bastillie is getting lynched tomorrow. Wait, so you were heavily against investigating blarg because of the risk of him being watched, but now that you think blarg maybe some kind of role that kills its visitors, which if true would kill hyper if he visits blarg, and that is suddenly NOT a big risk and you are pro targeting blarg? I don't follow that reasoning.
|
|
|
Post by LordofCastamere on Nov 18, 2015 2:29:11 GMT -8
Thanks Nin! Hopefully crab didn't forgot he can still post here even when he is banned. They're not gonna get fed up with him tomorrow. Especially with "Blarg lynching" turning into a scum tell. I see no reason to rush this. Unessceary risk. Again I say low activity tonight, high activity tomorrow. -- Hm, wait. "Solid." Blarg used that word in his last reasoning post with add emphasis. His first post was sneak, sneak = Solid Snake. What if Blarg is a neutral Bastille, or one of the Creevey brothers? Colin Creevey as a peeping tom is pretty damn good. Or, Oh shit. What if he attacks anyone that targets him? Look at him during the night and poof stone. I think changed my mind. Role hit him. If he's town, Mr Bastillie is getting lynched tomorrow. Wait, so you were heavily against investigating blarg because of the risk of him being watched, but now that you think blarg maybe some kind of role that kills its visitors, which if true would kill hyper if he visits blarg, and that is suddenly NOT a big risk and you are pro targeting blarg? I don't follow that reasoning. Still against it, but Hyper seems dead set and I think I capitalize on it regardless of what happens.
|
|
|
Post by Roytheone on Nov 18, 2015 5:27:33 GMT -8
So does kill: Swamped/Matt Attack RB: MA/Swamped Investigate: Blargonaut sound good? Now what about Arkos I went through RetroMG's posts in cthulhu day 1 where he tried to be recruited, seemed like the main thing would be that he referenced how he was insane and a post where he said he'd rather be claimed by cultiests than lynched Gonna go through how Darryl acted now in Animal Crossing, and then BananaSpacePrincess in Election Sound pretty good! I would prefer killing matt attack over swamped and would role block sawneeks instead of swamped, but I can live with this. Who would do the kill, me or crab? About Arkos, we could just do kalor, unless your search through the thread turned up something interesting. Also, about blarg being a veteran type deal: the only clear hint I could find was post 760 where he bolded that he is super dangerous. But that can also mean many different things, or it is just Blarg nonsense.
|
|
|
Post by Hyperactivity on Nov 18, 2015 5:34:44 GMT -8
crab should do it, we agreed.
If he's still here...
Yeah, main reason I don't want to RB Sawneeks is it seems like she's ordinary, part of the reason she's so out there right now
So Kill Matt Attack RB Swamped Poison Sawneeks Investigate Blargonaut Eavesdrop Kalor (for now)
|
|
|
Post by Arkos on Nov 18, 2015 9:11:28 GMT -8
Question: could we investigate Voldy but not discover that he is Voldy? I think that I am the only person that can discover who is Voldy. So are we possibly going to end up investigating + eavesdropping the same person (spending 2 nights' powers on then)? Blarg made me think of this because I also want to see if he is Voldy.
|
|
|
Post by Arkos on Nov 18, 2015 9:12:54 GMT -8
Sorry if it's not clear: it seems like we could end up "wasting" night powers without some strategy. You get me?
|
|
|
Post by Roytheone on Nov 18, 2015 9:21:33 GMT -8
Question: could we investigate Voldy but not discover that he is Voldy? I think that I am the only person that can discover who is Voldy. So are we possibly going to end up investigating + eavesdropping the same person (spending 2 nights' powers on then)? Blarg made me think of this because I also want to see if he is Voldy. To be honest, we don't know. We don't know what information Hyper gets back from his investigation. Maybe it's the role of the person, maybe it's the name, maybe it's both. We also don't know if Voldy is some kind of special case that doesn't follow the same rules as everyone else if hyper targets him (maybe hyper gets tom riddle back instead of voldy if he isn't activated yet for example). We know very little about what the voldermort role is precisely.
|
|
|
Post by Roytheone on Nov 18, 2015 9:26:34 GMT -8
Also, lets have a minute of silence for the poor Zippedpinhead who probably saw things he shouldn't have been able to see and now pays the price for that unfortunate incident.
|
|
|
Post by Ourobolus on Nov 18, 2015 9:44:21 GMT -8
Also, lets have a minute of silence for the poor Zippedpinhead who probably saw things he shouldn't have been able to see and now pays the price for that unfortunate incident. What happened? Another Launchpad/CornBurrito incident?
|
|
|
Post by Arkos on Nov 18, 2015 9:46:06 GMT -8
Okay then I will
Eavesdrop: Kalor
Tonight unless there are any objections
|
|
|
Post by Hyperactivity on Nov 18, 2015 9:47:41 GMT -8
Also, lets have a minute of silence for the poor Zippedpinhead who probably saw things he shouldn't have been able to see and now pays the price for that unfortunate incident. What happened? Another Launchpad/CornBurrito incident? lol, it must be a curse of mine put a timer on your neogaf accounts everyone, I wouldn't be surprised if everyone is banned by the end of this game
|
|
|
Post by TheExodu5 on Nov 18, 2015 10:18:49 GMT -8
Huh? What happened?
edit: was he stalking profiles on Outer Gafia? Or maybe trying to access hidden account information.
|
|
|
Post by Roytheone on Nov 18, 2015 10:22:46 GMT -8
Also, lets have a minute of silence for the poor Zippedpinhead who probably saw things he shouldn't have been able to see and now pays the price for that unfortunate incident. What happened? Another Launchpad/CornBurrito incident? sorta. The mods forgot to tell the new players that when they made an account on outer gafia, they should check the privacy option to hide their online status. Thus, a player, when looking at the members list I presume, saw some of (our?) scum team to be online a lot here, but never posting. So that person put A and B together and thus found like half (our?) scum team. Instead of (mis)using this information, he informed the mods of this, which BTW I REALLY appreciate. I don't know for sure it was part of our team that was outed and that it was Zipped, but based on the timing and the fact he can't say why he leaves the game, it isn't that hard to make that connection.
|
|
|
Post by TheExodu5 on Nov 18, 2015 10:24:32 GMT -8
*hats off* to good guy Zipped.
|
|
|
Post by Roytheone on Nov 18, 2015 10:33:42 GMT -8
Wait, now zipped is maybe not going to be replaced?
That will put us in kind of an awkward situation, since we now know zipped (probably) knows a bit more then the average town person. But acting on that is kind of shitty meta gaming which I am not a fan of.
|
|
|
Post by Hyperactivity on Nov 18, 2015 12:43:56 GMT -8
await, why not just replace him???
or have him switch with another player from another game???
|
|
|
Post by SalvaPot on Nov 18, 2015 12:46:33 GMT -8
He is getting replaced, but so that you guys know he saw only two of you guys in a list of 6 people, and he had no idea who was scum and who was not, I convinced him that it should be fine since a lot of players use outer gafia for stuff other than death eater chats, but nin convinced me that it may be a better idea to just replace him.
|
|
|
Post by Roytheone on Nov 18, 2015 12:55:39 GMT -8
He is getting replaced, but so that you guys know he saw only two of you guys in a list of 6 people, and he had no idea who was scum and who was not, I convinced him that it should be fine since a lot of players use outer gafia for stuff other than death eater chats, but nin convinced me that it may be a better idea to just replace him. Yeah, that would have probably be fine. But on the other hand you never know if it does come into play eventually. Btw, salva, am I allowed to send him a PM thanking him for being very fair about this and going to a mod instead of just using it?
|
|
Crab
Vice Admin
Glorious Leader
|
Post by Crab on Nov 18, 2015 15:03:53 GMT -8
I do keep up with this thread. I just haven't had much to say. It's N1; kill people you know have played good town games in the past and investigate people who you suspect softed roles or are generally nuisances. Blarg fits the latter category and Swamped is as good a choice as any for the former - particularly as she's so keen to not lynch, which I find moderately suspicious, plus the strange circle of trust thing. I'd like to do something about Burbeting at some point because I suspect he'll have some extra abilities as vanilla millers are unfun, also kingkitty and kalor and Kawl_UFC and Enker because I think they make insightful observations, and Gorlak, who is too enthusiastic not to have a good role.
|
|
Crab
Vice Admin
Glorious Leader
|
Post by Crab on Nov 18, 2015 15:11:49 GMT -8
I lean towards
Kill: Swamped, just to get her out the way Investigate: Burbeting if Hyperactivity gets role PM details, if just role name then Blargonaut Roleblock: Burbeting if Hyperactivity doesn't get role PM details, otherwise Gorlak
|
|