|
Post by Splinter on Oct 21, 2015 7:21:53 GMT -8
Do you want to tell them or do you want me to? Someone is going to tell them because I found it hilarious. I voted for Blarg. I swear I went back and read through the roles descriptions to make sure I wasn't messing with my win condition, but of course, that minuscule detail that we'd lose if the tanner team won wasn't in the role descriptions. Hey, let's all forget about that ok? i made the same mistake
|
|
|
Post by Sorian on Oct 21, 2015 7:21:51 GMT -8
Argh I knew he was the fucking minion. Sorian what would happen in a Blarg/LP tied vote? I would have had to have thought of some clever flavor to explain it but I would have awarded a win to both the Tanner team and Wolf team. Town carries the L all day, every day though.
|
|
|
Post by Sorian on Oct 21, 2015 7:23:18 GMT -8
I voted for Blarg. I swear I went back and read through the roles descriptions to make sure I wasn't messing with my win condition, but of course, that minuscule detail that we'd lose if the tanner team won wasn't in the role descriptions. Hey, let's all forget about that ok? i made the same mistake Duly noted, I probably could have been clearer with that in both posts. This is why I say to read everything though
|
|
|
Post by Splinter on Oct 21, 2015 7:23:23 GMT -8
Argh I knew he was the fucking minion. Sorian what would happen in a Blarg/LP tied vote? I would have had to have thought of some clever flavor to explain it but I would have awarded a win to both the Tanner team and Wolf team. Town carries the L all day, every day though.I'm ok with this
|
|
|
Post by Coppanuva on Oct 21, 2015 7:23:57 GMT -8
I mean other than that I think I played pretty well. You definitely did. I burst out laughing at your whole "I know my tag says I'm always a werewolf guys, but I'm not this time" thing on day 1. That was amazing. Also it's ok on the voting thing, I almost voted Blargonaut (I skipped over the Tanner team is the only one who wins if he's lynched clause), but I was pretty certain you were still a wolf and L_P wasn't. Nobody was claiming to have switched either of you, and the converted werewolf changed himself back (I was going to do it on blargonaut until he was protected).
|
|
|
Post by Fireblend on Oct 21, 2015 7:24:17 GMT -8
Also winning as a wolf while having a tag that says I'm always a wolf should award me some sort of something. I feel pretty good about that.
|
|
|
Post by Lone_Prodigy on Oct 21, 2015 7:26:19 GMT -8
I suck at lying.
|
|
|
Post by Coppanuva on Oct 21, 2015 7:37:01 GMT -8
No way man, it was exactly that level of skill at lying that won it for wolf team! You somehow managed to be the most suspicious person in 2 separate possibilities, which made you the obvious choice (which was perfect!). As a minion, you played ridiculously well. Also since Sorian hasn't edited his post with our roles redacted: I was Alpha wolf.
|
|
|
Post by Sorian on Oct 21, 2015 7:38:34 GMT -8
Things I Messed Up OnBecause there is always something. I made only one flub as far as I can see or remember. When I sent L_P's minion post, he should have only received Coppa and Fire's names. I did add Ouro's name when I should not have. The reasoning for this is that the minion sees anyone who thinks they are a wolf. Ouro was unaware of his wolfness so he would not have shown up to the meeting where the minion spies. MY BAD. But it had no effect on the proceedings, it became obvious super fast once you guy's actually started discussing that Ouro was a wolf and switched it away. That being said let's segue way to: End of Game Thoughts You guys were killing me with the lack of discussion for the first 15ish hours? Definitely gimped your ability to deduce a full role list. I think the main moral of the story here is that you can't assume someone will come forward because there are the 4 cards in the middle (thinking on it, I forgot to post this): Card 1: Seer Card 2: Mason 2 Card 3: Cursed Card 4: Werewolf So grats to Coppa for lying about his Seer claim but still being 100% right about the cards in the slots he chose. But yeah, you all sat on your hands waiting for that seer and if a wolf had decided to be bold even earlier, you all would have followed them down whatever path they wanted. I also enjoyed that Hyper was still calling for someone to claim Cursed with less than an hour left. Never forget that some things have to be in the middle. Hmmmmm, I'm going to give MVP to Lone_Prodigy. He did a fantastic job of garnering suspicion and if *Splinter hadn't played that last minute gambit, I highly doubt this would have been as close as it was. Splinter gets honorary mention. I would have given you MVP but I'm letting L_P take it by a nose because I see that your gambit was not a bold faced lie but instead just you missing rules in the OP which isn't as fun.
|
|
|
Post by Sorian on Oct 21, 2015 7:39:23 GMT -8
No way man, it was exactly that level of skill at lying that won it for wolf team! You somehow managed to be the most suspicious person in 2 separate possibilities, which made you the obvious choice (which was perfect!). As a minion, you played ridiculously well. Also since Sorian hasn't edited his post with our roles redacted: I was Alpha wolf. Oh yes sorry,
Coppanuva as the Alpha Wolf Fireblend as the Mystic Wolf Lone_Prodigy as the Minion
|
|
|
Post by Splinter on Oct 21, 2015 7:46:43 GMT -8
Things I Messed Up OnBecause there is always something. I made only one flub as far as I can see or remember. When I sent L_P's minion post, he should have only received Coppa and Fire's names. I did add Ouro's name when I should not have. The reasoning for this is that the minion sees anyone who thinks they are a wolf. Ouro was unaware of his wolfness so he would not have shown up to the meeting where the minion spies. MY BAD. But it had no effect on the proceedings, it became obvious super fast once you guy's actually started discussing that Ouro was a wolf and switched it away. That being said let's segue way to: End of Game Thoughts You guys were killing me with the lack of discussion for the first 15ish hours? Definitely gimped your ability to deduce a full role list. I think the main moral of the story here is that you can't assume someone will come forward because there are the 4 cards in the middle (thinking on it, I forgot to post this): Card 1: Seer Card 2: Mason 2 Card 3: Cursed Card 4: Werewolf So grats to Coppa for lying about his Seer claim but still being 100% right about the cards in the slots he chose. But yeah, you all sat on your hands waiting for that seer and if a wolf had decided to be bold even earlier, you all would have followed them down whatever path they wanted. I also enjoyed that Hyper was still calling for someone to claim Cursed with less than an hour left. Never forget that some things have to be in the middle. Hmmmmm, I'm going to give MVP to Lone_Prodigy. He did a fantastic job of garnering suspicion and if *Splinter hadn't played that last minute gambit, I highly doubt this would have been as close as it was. Splinter gets honorary mention. I would have given you MVP but I'm letting L_P take it by a nose because I see that your gambit was not a bold faced lie but instead just you missing rules in the OP which isn't as fun. So I lost "by a nose" twice in this game? /sigh Who the hell voted for me?
|
|
|
Post by Sorian on Oct 21, 2015 7:48:06 GMT -8
I should also ask:
Did everyone feel like this role distribution was much more balanced? I know it blows ONUW 5 out of the water but I'm pretty pleased with how these roles interacted with each other.
Also, thoughts on the Tanner's Wife role and how it went? I'm aware that a troublemaker or witch can mess up the whole teams chance at winning but its similar to the minion. If the trouble maker had switch Hyper and L_P instead, you know L_P would have been posting wolf names ASAP so it just comes down to smart/lucky night action play and then the people that were named and their ability to lie. I think *Splinter proved that even when a switched teammate sells you out, you can still run a gambit with a high chance of success.
|
|
|
Post by Sorian on Oct 21, 2015 7:49:46 GMT -8
Things I Messed Up OnBecause there is always something. I made only one flub as far as I can see or remember. When I sent L_P's minion post, he should have only received Coppa and Fire's names. I did add Ouro's name when I should not have. The reasoning for this is that the minion sees anyone who thinks they are a wolf. Ouro was unaware of his wolfness so he would not have shown up to the meeting where the minion spies. MY BAD. But it had no effect on the proceedings, it became obvious super fast once you guy's actually started discussing that Ouro was a wolf and switched it away. That being said let's segue way to: End of Game Thoughts You guys were killing me with the lack of discussion for the first 15ish hours? Definitely gimped your ability to deduce a full role list. I think the main moral of the story here is that you can't assume someone will come forward because there are the 4 cards in the middle (thinking on it, I forgot to post this): Card 1: Seer Card 2: Mason 2 Card 3: Cursed Card 4: Werewolf So grats to Coppa for lying about his Seer claim but still being 100% right about the cards in the slots he chose. But yeah, you all sat on your hands waiting for that seer and if a wolf had decided to be bold even earlier, you all would have followed them down whatever path they wanted. I also enjoyed that Hyper was still calling for someone to claim Cursed with less than an hour left. Never forget that some things have to be in the middle. Hmmmmm, I'm going to give MVP to Lone_Prodigy. He did a fantastic job of garnering suspicion and if *Splinter hadn't played that last minute gambit, I highly doubt this would have been as close as it was. Splinter gets honorary mention. I would have given you MVP but I'm letting L_P take it by a nose because I see that your gambit was not a bold faced lie but instead just you missing rules in the OP which isn't as fun. So I lost "by a nose" twice in this game? /sigh Who the hell voted for me? You are number one in their heart at least! I'll let them reveal or not at their own discretion. It was a town member which is all I will say.
|
|
|
Post by Roytheone on Oct 21, 2015 7:51:42 GMT -8
BOOOOOO, I am no longer part of the only wolf win in Gafia history. Also, you guys didn't lynch Fireblend and look at what that brought you: town lost. If you had lynched fireblend you would have won. ALWAYS BE LYNCHING FIREBLEND!!!
|
|
|
Post by Sorian on Oct 21, 2015 7:53:35 GMT -8
Things I Messed Up OnBecause there is always something. I made only one flub as far as I can see or remember. When I sent L_P's minion post, he should have only received Coppa and Fire's names. I did add Ouro's name when I should not have. The reasoning for this is that the minion sees anyone who thinks they are a wolf. Ouro was unaware of his wolfness so he would not have shown up to the meeting where the minion spies. MY BAD. But it had no effect on the proceedings, it became obvious super fast once you guy's actually started discussing that Ouro was a wolf and switched it away. That being said let's segue way to: End of Game Thoughts You guys were killing me with the lack of discussion for the first 15ish hours? Definitely gimped your ability to deduce a full role list. I think the main moral of the story here is that you can't assume someone will come forward because there are the 4 cards in the middle (thinking on it, I forgot to post this): Card 1: Seer Card 2: Mason 2 Card 3: Cursed Card 4: Werewolf So grats to Coppa for lying about his Seer claim but still being 100% right about the cards in the slots he chose. But yeah, you all sat on your hands waiting for that seer and if a wolf had decided to be bold even earlier, you all would have followed them down whatever path they wanted. I also enjoyed that Hyper was still calling for someone to claim Cursed with less than an hour left. Never forget that some things have to be in the middle. Hmmmmm, I'm going to give MVP to Lone_Prodigy. He did a fantastic job of garnering suspicion and if *Splinter hadn't played that last minute gambit, I highly doubt this would have been as close as it was. Splinter gets honorary mention. I would have given you MVP but I'm letting L_P take it by a nose because I see that your gambit was not a bold faced lie but instead just you missing rules in the OP which isn't as fun. So I lost "by a nose" twice in this game? /sigh Who the hell voted for me? Also, don't take it too hard. I've been dreaming of a Tanner win since we started ONUW and you came the closest to delivering ever. If you look back to past games, the Tanner has never even received a vote from anyone except for the tanner. You got members from both wolf team and town team to vote for Blarg. You were awesome.
|
|
|
Post by Fireblend on Oct 21, 2015 7:54:11 GMT -8
BOOOOOO, I am no longer part of the only wolf win in Gafia history. Also, you guys didn't lynch Fireblend and look at what that brought you: town lost. If you had lynched fireblend you would have won. ALWAYS BE LYNCHING FIREBLEND!!! This is not the right takeaway. The right takeaway is: Always be hoping Fireblend is on your side ;)
|
|
|
Post by zippedpinhead on Oct 21, 2015 7:56:00 GMT -8
Fireblend fooled me utterly. fireblend's last minute doppel fake out that switched me and terrabyte. That lie was so reasonable I believed it. Convinced me to vote Blarg (as I thought I was the tanner's wife.
well played wolves...
you win this time. and either way I would have lost.
|
|
|
Post by Sorian on Oct 21, 2015 7:58:13 GMT -8
BOOOOOO, I am no longer part of the only wolf win in Gafia history. Also, you guys didn't lynch Fireblend and look at what that brought you: town lost. If you had lynched fireblend you would have won. ALWAYS BE LYNCHING FIREBLEND!!! This is not the right takeaway. The right takeaway is: Always be hoping Fireblend is on your side I think the RNG site I use always makes Blarg a tanner and Fire a wolf.
Someone halp.
|
|
|
Post by Roytheone on Oct 21, 2015 7:59:57 GMT -8
BOOOOOO, I am no longer part of the only wolf win in Gafia history. Also, you guys didn't lynch Fireblend and look at what that brought you: town lost. If you had lynched fireblend you would have won. ALWAYS BE LYNCHING FIREBLEND!!! This is not the right takeaway. The right takeaway is: Always be hoping Fireblend is on your side I was on your side once, and I still lynched you. And guess what? We won! ALWAYS BE LYNCHING FIREBLEND!!!!
|
|
|
Post by Lone_Prodigy on Oct 21, 2015 8:09:58 GMT -8
I voted for myself. Splinter almost ruined it for us. I just played like I did in Cthulhu.
|
|
|
Post by Coppanuva on Oct 21, 2015 8:10:18 GMT -8
This is not the right takeaway. The right takeaway is: Always be hoping Fireblend is on your side I was on your side once, and I still lynched you. And guess what? We won! ALWAYS BE LYNCHING FIREBLEND!!!! No no roytheone, not lynching Fireblend was the correct strategy here.
|
|
|
Post by Sorian on Oct 21, 2015 8:15:37 GMT -8
I voted for myself. Splinter almost ruined it for us. I just played like I did in Cthulhu. Blarg also voted for himself so you two were a wash. I really hope Blarg gets to be a not-tanner next time.
|
|
|
Post by Coppanuva on Oct 21, 2015 8:22:16 GMT -8
I voted for myself. Splinter almost ruined it for us. I just played like I did in Cthulhu. Blarg also voted for himself so you two were a wash. I really hope Blarg gets to be a not-tanner next time. Yeah same... he would have changed too if it weren't for that meddling Sentinel!
|
|
|
Post by Sawneeks on Oct 21, 2015 8:24:19 GMT -8
Things I Messed Up OnBecause there is always something. I made only one flub as far as I can see or remember. When I sent L_P's minion post, he should have only received Coppa and Fire's names. I did add Ouro's name when I should not have. The reasoning for this is that the minion sees anyone who thinks they are a wolf. Ouro was unaware of his wolfness so he would not have shown up to the meeting where the minion spies. MY BAD. But it had no effect on the proceedings, it became obvious super fast once you guy's actually started discussing that Ouro was a wolf and switched it away. That being said let's segue way to: End of Game Thoughts You guys were killing me with the lack of discussion for the first 15ish hours? Definitely gimped your ability to deduce a full role list. I think the main moral of the story here is that you can't assume someone will come forward because there are the 4 cards in the middle (thinking on it, I forgot to post this): Card 1: Seer Card 2: Mason 2 Card 3: Cursed Card 4: Werewolf So grats to Coppa for lying about his Seer claim but still being 100% right about the cards in the slots he chose. But yeah, you all sat on your hands waiting for that seer and if a wolf had decided to be bold even earlier, you all would have followed them down whatever path they wanted. I also enjoyed that Hyper was still calling for someone to claim Cursed with less than an hour left. Never forget that some things have to be in the middle. Hmmmmm, I'm going to give MVP to Lone_Prodigy. He did a fantastic job of garnering suspicion and if *Splinter hadn't played that last minute gambit, I highly doubt this would have been as close as it was. Splinter gets honorary mention. I would have given you MVP but I'm letting L_P take it by a nose because I see that your gambit was not a bold faced lie but instead just you missing rules in the OP which isn't as fun. So I lost "by a nose" twice in this game? /sigh Who the hell voted for me? But guys Splinter is the Wolf and L_P is a Minion!!
|
|
|
Post by Sorian on Oct 21, 2015 8:25:19 GMT -8
So I lost "by a nose" twice in this game? /sigh Who the hell voted for me? But guys Splinter is the Wolf and L_P is a Minion!! <3 you.
I laughed because I got a string of L_P votes really fast then opened yours and saw Splinter.
|
|
|
Post by Lone_Prodigy on Oct 21, 2015 8:28:17 GMT -8
I did think Ouro was a wolf and thought his claim was very well done.
|
|
|
Post by Ourobolus on Oct 21, 2015 8:30:39 GMT -8
I did think Ouro was a wolf and thought his claim was very well done. There was a reason I was really focused on Hyper's post about the Alpha Wolf and Drunk. I needed to make sure.
|
|
|
Post by Lone_Prodigy on Oct 21, 2015 8:30:43 GMT -8
So I lost "by a nose" twice in this game? /sigh Who the hell voted for me? But guys Splinter is the Wolf and L_P is a Minion!! I think with a more active town you could've convinced more people that I was the Minion.
|
|
|
Post by Ourobolus on Oct 21, 2015 8:31:34 GMT -8
I had a sneaking suspicion, but it was too late for me to really try to gather a group of people to vote for Coppa.
|
|
|
Post by Sawneeks on Oct 21, 2015 8:42:35 GMT -8
But guys Splinter is the Wolf and L_P is a Minion!! <3 you.
I laughed because I got a string of L_P votes really fast then opened yours and saw Splinter.
hehehe, glad I could provide a good laugh. But guys Splinter is the Wolf and L_P is a Minion!! I think with a more active town you could've convinced more people that I was the Minion. Maybe? I think as long as the more active members were trying to get you lynched nothing would have really changed. :c Even then I didn't even question Coppa or Fire as being wolves. Coppa's Seer claim was weird but it made sense so I didn't question it and Fire blend skated under my radar. Good game though! Congrats to the wolves for a solid victory.
|
|