In times like these, I ask myself: Should we have used my Roleblocks more instead of Mazre's Redirects?
The answer, dear audience-who-I-know-is-totally-somewhere, is a resounding NO
Redirection is a FAR better, more utilitarian Power than Roleblocking.
While yes, of course, in successfully Roleblocking the killer or Redirecting the killer to your target-of-choice, both outcomes supply you with the identity of said killer; however, I BELIEVE it is vastly more preferable to have the off-chance of making the Mafia kill one of their own via the latter, as opposed to having a deathless Night via the former
risk, reward etc.
anyway, back to coping with the inevitability of death
Blargonaut almost said: "Your Plan of City's Last Hope: This is it. I don't trust any of you "Town" voters to be able to lynch a Mafia Today.
Not only are the odds of hitting a Mafia against us, but with no actionable intel from any other Town PRs besides me and Mazre's 3 Nights of player Redirects (which confirm that bats and Trigger weren't killers on N1 and N3 respectively), we've also all been operating in complete info darkness.
So, I'm saying this now with the assumption that at the end of Today, in all possible timelines, Town's gonna fuck it up by lynching another Town... thereby launching the remnants of Town into LYLO Tomorrow. Like it or not, LYLO Tomorrow is the outcome of greatest likelihood after Today. This is not being grim, this is being realistic.
However, we can choose to mitigate this inevitable damage and give us the best chances of Turning this Undead in Town's favour Tomorrow, if we do exactly as I say below:
[*]The real Town Investigator MUST claim and reveal themselves Today, and publicly state their Investigation results for the past N1, N2 and N3. [*]Then, we must LYNCH the Town Investigator, Today. [*]This way, by flipping them: - By killing the real Investigator right now, we will confirm without a doubt that the Town Investigator really is who they say they are, therefore we can absolutely trust their stated results. - By killing the real Investigator right now, we will have prevented the Mafia from faking one of themselves as the Town Investigator Tomorrow (because game balance-wise, a game usually never has 2 Town Investigators), thereby preventing the most dangerous, fatal-to-Town Mafia ploy from happening during Tomorrow's LYLO.
I don't want you to panic and go all 'WTFFFFF BLARG FUCK YOU'-reactive about what I'm saying here. Think about this.
Consider that Tomorrow will highly likely be LYLO. Consider what Mafia will do during LYLO to win. Consider how the currently still-living Town Investigator and their claim's credibility will factor when in a LYLO situation.
If you consider all three of these factors together... you would come to the same conclusion. I'm sorry. If we want the best shot at Town winning, we have to do this Today.
Town Investigator, please come forward and state your results for N1, N2 and N3. Then, we must lynch you.